Select the search type
  • Site
  • Web

CanoeingLynx and PartridgeWalleye Rising

Honoring the pride of the Northland!  We serve to highlight our communities with honest reporting as progress is dependent on facts.  The Northland 

is rich with outdoor activities and beautiful landscapes found in few places around the world.  We respect the need to preserve our environment while 

also allowing for the sustainable incomes and livelihoods of our residents.  Both are needed and possible. . .

(Pictures courtesy of

Northland Watch:  When you want or need your news fast!  The only place you're going to find the good and bad in your community.

The Department of Energy needs to Defunded

The Department of Energy needs to Defunded




Funding Highlights:


Provides $29.5 billion, a 12 percent increase over the 2010 enacted level.  This reflects increases for priority areas such as clean energy, nuclear security, and research and development.  Savings are achieved through cuts to inefficient fossil energy programs.  [This 12% increase if further encroachment on the free market system.  Clean energy, as well as research and development, should be left to the private sector, not the federal government.  Secondly, nuclear security should fall under the Department of Defense outlays.  Third, fossil energy, while not popular with some, is still maintains the highest efficiency of all fuels.  If it were not, alternative, clean energies would already be in place.]


Doubles the number of Energy Innovation Hubs, adding three areas of research to focus on critical materials including rare earth materials, battery and energy storage, and new grid technologies and systems to help Smart Grid and improve energy transmission efficiency.  [This too should be left to the private sector.]

Positions the United States to lead in the clean energy economy by providing $5.4 billion for long-term research and development at the Office of Science and $550 million for the Advanced Research Projects Agency–Energy.  [This money should not come on the backs of taxpayers or governed by the Dept. of Energy.]


Makes a significant commitment to U.S. energy technology leadership, more than doubling energy efficiency research, development, and deployment and increasing renewable energy investments by over 70 percent.  [The government is meddling in areas best left to the private sector and free enterprise to develop.]


Initiates a public-private effort to reduce energy usage in our Nation’s commercial buildings by 20 percent by 2020.  The Department of Energy’s programs include a “Race to Green” grant competition and a pilot program to provide retrofit loan guarantees that will focus on universities and hospitals.  These programs complement an expanded and redesigned tax incentive for commercial building upgrades.  [The commercial sector needs the federal government to withdraw for micromanaging and over-regulating them out of existence.  Let businesses decide for themselves what cost savings to pursue.  The programs, regulations, and oversight do nothing but draw much needed resources away from businesses, particularly one's struggling to get off the ground.]


Helps reach the goal of one million advanced technology vehicles on the road by 2015 through more than $580 million to assist in research and development, a competitive grant program to support deployment in communities across the country, and enhancements to the existing electric vehicle tax incentive.


[Government mandates are not the answer, but part of the problem.  Mandates artificially prop up inefficient energies that could not otherwise survive in the free market.  The reason they would not survive is that they are not competitively priced and efficient.]


Increases the percentage of electricity produced by clean energy sources by encouraging early commercial deployment of innovative clean energy technologies with additional loan guarantee support for nuclear power plants and innovative energy efficiency and renewable energy projects. This financing support complements tax incentives (e.g., Section 1603 grants and Section 48c credits) for renewable energy generation and manufacturing.  [Tax incentives are simply subsidies paid by taxpayers.]


Eliminates inefficient fossil fuel subsidies that impede investment in clean energy sources and undermine efforts to address the threat of climate change.  [Remove all subsidies from fossil fuels and clean energies and let them compete in the open market.  The claim of climate change is highly unsubstantiated.  It is being used by "big government" puppet masters to redistribute wealth.]


Includes $7.6 billion to maintain a safe, secure, and effective nuclear weapons stockpile in support of the planned decrease in deployed U.S. and Russian weapons under the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty approved by the Senate.74 [This program should be financed under the Department of Defense.]

Strengthens national security through funding for the detection, elimination, and securing of nuclear and radiological material worldwide. [This program should be financed under the Department of Defense.]


Continues the Nation’s efforts to reduce environmental risks and safely manage nuclear materials. [This program should be financed under the Department of Defense.]


The Department of Energy (DOE) is charged with advancing the national, economic, and energy security of the United States; promoting scientific and technological innovation in support of that mission; and ensuring the environmental cleanup of the national nuclear weapons complex. It facilitates some of the President’s highest priorities: clean energy and research and development (R&D), which are critical to the Nation’s economic competitiveness and national security. [If the purpose of the President is seek economic competitiveness, the government would withdraw from its improper place in the energy field.  The United States has vast natural gas and oil reserves in oil shale the President has restrained.  They also have the larges coal reserves in the world, they could use safely via underground coal gasification.]  The President’s Budget provides $29.5 billion for DOE to support this mission, a 12 percent increase over the 2010 enacted level.  While funding has been increased in these critical areas, the Administration has identified areas for savings, such as certain fossil energy programs where industry has the resources to move forward without Federal assistance.


Invests in the Clean Energy Economy and Jobs of the Future


Doubles the Number of Energy Innovation Hubs.  Energy Innovation Hubs will bring together top scientists to work in teams on cross-disciplinary research related to critical materials and rare earth elements, energy storage and bat¬teries, and the development of new grid technologies and systems to help Smart Grids improve energy transmission efficiency.  Innovation and breakthroughs often happen when scientists and thinkers from different disciplines have a chance to work together on some of our toughest problems. This was the approach undertaken in the Manhattan Project and in the effort to develop radar.  As we look at the challenges facing the Nation, especially those related to clean energy, we need to foster this kind of creativity. That is why the Budget doubles the number of Energy Innovation Hubs, creating three more Hubs across the country.  These new Hubs will join existing Hubs on fuels from sunlight, energy efficient buildings, and modeling and simulation technologies for nuclear power.  [This is what the private sector has already been doing and always has.  Why should taxpayers carry this cost when there is no clear benefit?]


Funds Clean Energy Research, Development, and Deployment to Keep America Competitive.  To lead in the industries of tomorrow, it is critical that we invest in R&D today.  The Budget advances the President’s Plan for Science and Innovation to double the budgets of key basic research agencies, providing $5.4 billion for the Office of Science, including $2.0 billion for basic energy sciences to discover new ways to produce, store, and use energy.  These funds are part of a broad energy strategy that starts with research and includes deployment through grants, financing assistance, and tax incentives. Compared to 2010, the Budget more than doubles funding for energy efficiency activities to improve the energy productivity of our industries, vehicles, and buildings.  It ramps up support for renewable energy research, development, and deployment activities by over 70 percent, including: $457 million for solar energy; $341 million for biofuels and biomass R&D, including a new reverse auction to promote advanced biofuels; and more than doubling investment in geothermal energy to $102 million. It also includes: $853 million to support nuclear energy, including research and development of a variety of nuclear technologies, such as Small Modular Reactors; and $453 million for a fossil energy R&D portfolio focused on carbon capture and storage technologies.  [The government is taking the place of private investments, making all taxpaying citizens unwilling participants of their ideologies.]  The Budget includes funding to accelerate the deployment of new models of energy research pioneered in the last several years, including $550 million for the Advanced Research Projects Agency–Energy, a program that supports breakthrough ideas.  Finally, building on the unprecedented investment in clean energy provided by the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act of 2009 (the Recovery Act), the Budget provides $36 billion in loan guarantee authority for new nuclear power facilities and an additional $200 million in credit subsidy to support $1 billion to $2 billion in loan guarantees for innovative energy efficiency and renewable energy projects, and proposes new loan authority to improve the efficiency of commercial buildings, hospitals and schools.  [Eliminate all subsidies, and do not be insurers of any product.]


Reduces Buildings’ Energy Use by 20 Percent by 2020. The 80 billion square feet of non-residential building space in the United States present an opportunity to realize large gains in energy efficiency.  In 2010, commercial buildings consumed roughly 20 percent of all energy in the U.S. economy. The President’s Better Buildings Initiative will, over the next 10 years, seek to make non-residential buildings 20 percent more energy efficient by catalyzing private sector investment through a series of incentives to upgrade offices, stores, universities, schools, hos¬pitals and other commercial buildings.  The Budget proposes to make American businesses more energy efficient through three new initiatives: re-designing the current tax deduction for commercial buildings and upgrades by changing it to a credit and increasing the program by $1 billion; launching two new pilot projects that focus on increasing financing opportunities for universities, schools, and hospitals by providing loan guaran¬tees; and creating a $100 million “Race to Green” competition for State and municipal governments to implement innovative approaches to build¬ing codes, standards, and performance measurements so that commercial building efficiency will become the norm. These programs build on the Administration’s commitment to retrofitting residential and government buildings, particularly through the Recovery Act investments and the Administration’s proposed Homestar program.  The Administration continues to call on the Congress to pass the Homestar bill, which would create jobs by encouraging Americans to invest in energy saving home improvements.  [The Homestar program, like most government programs, place a tax on the population via incentives, credits, and loan guarantees.  This "tax" is then used to employ some that the administration quickly touts as a "job creation" program.  The government is the last place that should be employing individuals in the private sector, as they have a long history of making things too bureaucratic, expensive, and scandalous.]


Helps Put One Million Advanced Technology Vehicles on the Road by 2015. To reach this goal and become the first in the world to do so, the Budget proposes new efforts to support electric vehicle manufacturing and adoption in the United States.  The Budget transforms the existing $7,500 tax credit for electric vehicles into a rebate that will be available to all consumers immediately at the point of sale, and advances innovative technologies through new R&D investments, building on the Recovery Act investments.  In addition, the Budget proposes an investment of $588 million for vehicle technologies—an increase of 88 percent above current funding lev¬els, including a new effort to reward communities that invest in electric vehicles and infrastructure and remove regulatory barriers through a $200 million grant program, modeled after the Race to the Top program.  [The ethanol industry has shown that once you start a government program, no matter the size, you create a beast that is hard to kill.  This was a tremendous waste of government money that accomplished little but run up more than $45 billion in subsidies (taxes).]


Modernizes the Electric Grid. The Budget continues to support the modernization of the Nation’s electric grid by investing in research, development, and demonstration of Smart Grid technologies.  This effort will spur the transition to a smarter, more efficient, secure and reliable electric system.  As part of this effort, the Budget supports a new Energy Innovation Hub that will focus on grid technologies.  The end result will promote energy- and cost-saving choices for consumers, reduce emissions, and foster the growth of renewable energy sources like wind and solar. In addition, the Budget supports the Power Marketing Administrations to reliably operate, maintain, and rehabilitate the Federal hydropower and transmission systems.  [This should be left to the private sector, not the federal government.]


Eliminates Inefficient Fossil Fuel Subsidies. Consistent with the Administration’s Government-wide effort to identify areas for savings, the Budget eliminates inefficient fossil fuel subsidies that impede investment in clean energy sources and undermine efforts to address the threat of climate change.  Approximately $4 billion per year in tax subsidies to oil, gas, and other fossil fuel producers are proposed for repeal.  [The federal government should eliminate all subsidies, including those they have and propose for alternative energy development.]


Protects Americans from the Threat of Nuclear Harm and Pollution


Modernizes the Nation’s Nuclear Weapons Arsenal, Reduces Proliferation Risks, and Maintains a Strong Strategic Deterrent.  The Administration proposes $11.8 billion in new budget authority for the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA), $1.9 billion more than the 2010 enacted level. The overall investment includes $7.6 billion for Weapons Activities, an increase of $1.2 billion over the 2010 enacted level, to maintain a safe, secure, and effective nuclear arsenal by improving and replacing aging facilities and infrastructure, continuing nuclear weapon life extension programs, and sustaining stockpile surveillance and certification activities.  This is the first of a multi-year effort, consistent with the report on the nuclear weapons infra-structure submitted to the Congress in November 2010.  This multi-year funding is included in the outyear Budget assumptions and will be included in NNSA’s budget each year.  The Administration also proposes $2.5 billion to prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons by fully funding efforts to secure and dispose of nuclear material, to develop technologies to detect and deter nuclear testing and smuggling, and to support international nonproliferation treaties, regulatory controls, and safeguards.  The Administration also proposes $1.2 billion for the work on naval reactors, including design of a new spent fuel handling infrastructure and reactor development for a replacement to the Ohio Class ballistic missile submarine to sustain a robust nuclear deterrent.  Finally, reflecting their close partnership and shared commitment, a portion of future funding for NNSA will be included in the Department of Defense’s budget, with allocations being made to NNSA each budget year.  [This should be solely listed in the defense budget.]


Protects the Public from Harmful Exposure to Radioactive Waste and Nuclear Materials. The Environmental Management program continues to clean up waste and contamination to meet its cleanup commitments at sites used for nuclear weapons production and energy research.  The program’s cleanup actions include removing radioactive wastes from underground storage tanks, decontaminating and decommis¬sioning old production facilities, and installing groundwater monitoring wells primarily at sites in Washington, South Carolina, Idaho, Tennessee, and New Mexico.  [This should be solely listed in the defense budget.]


The Budget for Fiscal Year 2012, pp. 75-78, provided by the OMB for 2012.  Find it at


This is clearly a department that has no right to exist, as it does nothing but wrongfully encroach on the private sector.  The defense spending outlays rightfully belong with the Department of Defense.


Writer Marvin Pirila has added the underlines to highlight subtitles, and financial outlays.  His comments are included in brackets [ ].